FELDSTED: Why would our Prime Minister undermine negotiations before they happen? … what emerges is a government in disarray
Liberals
won’t appeal Trans Mountain ruling, name former justice to oversee new
Indigenous consultations
~~ Amanda Connolly ~~ Global News ~~ October 3, 2018
~~ Amanda Connolly ~~ Global News ~~ October 3, 2018
The Liberals will not appeal a court ruling that
found they failed to adequately consult with Indigenous stakeholders on the
Trans Mountain pipeline expansion. Natural
Resources Minister Amarjeet Sohi made the announcement Wednesday morning in
Ottawa.
Speaking to reporters, Sohi said the government
will redo consultations with all 117 Indigenous groups affected by the project. Former Supreme Court justice Frank Iacobucci
has also been appointed to oversee these new consultations.
In August, a Federal Court ruling hit the brakes on
the Trans Mountain expansion project, which will triple the capacity of an
existing pipeline to carry crude oil to the BC coast. That ruling flagged two major issues with the
project: first, that the initial approval by the National Energy Board was
fundamentally flawed for not considering the impact of the expansion and
increased tanker traffic on marine ecosystems and second, that the current
Liberal government failed in its duty to consult adequately during the latest
Phase 3 round of talks with Indigenous communities.
For full story CLICK HERE:
The flaw in pipeline assessment is regulations that
requires upstream, and downstream, assessment of product moved in a pipeline.
That is ridiculous overkill and rationally unsupportable.
Upstream are production facilities; those producers
who pull up raw product from the ground. All of them are separately assessed
and face regulations on their operation designed to minimize carbon emissions.
Downstream are the operations that will use
products moved by pipelines, again regulated by governments respecting carbon
emissions if resident in Canada. If the operation is in a foreign country,
downstream assessment is ridiculous.
If we are competing in an open market, we cannot
refuse to export to a given nation because it is not on the climate change
reduction plan. Under that thinking, we cannot export to the USA as it has
withdrawn from the Paris accord.
It takes a wondrous flight of fancy to decide that
the National Energy Board (NEB) must consider how the Trans Mountain pipeline
project will influence tanker traffic, and the whale population, on west cost.
Protection of marine species is under the Natural Resources and Oceans and
Fisheries departments. That is already regulated. Furthermore, tanker traffic along with huge
container ships and ocean liners, are regulated as all have substantial stores
of motive fuel and lubricants that can result in damaging spills.
Protection of coastal waters against accidental
spills employs known technology. The
higher the risk, the more need for adequate equipment and crews trained to deal
with containing and cleaning up a spill.
Whether that spill originated from an overturned rail car, a barge which
has run aground, a boat or ship hitting a reef or the shore -- action is
required. That role is usually carried out by the Coast Guard with assistance
from specialist private contractors.
The article above is disconcerting:
“Where possible, the government will try to offer accommodations to
indigenous communities to relieve their concerns. But if groups remain opposed after the
government has fulfilled its consultation requirements, it will still go
forward.”
Why would Prime Minister Justin Trudeau undermine negotiations
before they happen? That is not good faith dealing, that will advance
reconciliation. The well is poisoned before the first water is
drawn.
What emerges is a government in disarray ... having several departments and agencies tripping
over one another is inane.
Concerns dealing with marine species, and ocean
traffic, are dealt with by appropriate departments. Allow them to fulfill their
mandates without interference from the National Energy Board.
Too many cooks produce an inedible stew.
John Feldsted
Political Consultant
& Strategist
Winnipeg, Manitoba
Comments
Post a Comment