JOHN FELDSTED -- Taxpayer funds to buy votes in major metropolitan centres -- meddling in provincial affairs
CBC NEWS: Ottawa to invest $1.3 billion in Blue line extension --
the investment corresponds to about a third of the expected total cost
It is
hard to know where to begin with what is wrong with this announcement. For
starters, it is just in time for the fall federal election.
Local infrastructure
is a provincial jurisdiction. The federal government has no constitutional
authority to spend money on local infrastructure unless:
- The subway connects Quebec with another province or port; or
- The subway is of benefit to two or more provinces; or
- The subway can be declared of benefit to Canada as a whole.
Secondly,
we have to look at populations and shares of cost. When sort through that:
- The City of Montreal is putting up about $1.995 billion
- Quebecers living outside of Montreal are putting up about $1.497 billion; and
- Canadian living outside of Quebec are putting up about $1 billion.
As a
Manitoba resident I have a problem with subsidizing a subway in Montreal.
Budget
2016 committed $14.4 billion focused on accelerating federal investments
in the short term by providing funding for the rehabilitation, repair, and
modernization of existing public transit, green and social infrastructure.
Additional funding was targeted towards post-secondary education and broadband
access for remote communities.
Budget
2017 made an additional $81.2 billion of funding available across five
priority infrastructure streams: public transit, green, social, trade and
transportation, and rural and northern communities' infrastructure.
Our
federal government has created two programs. The Smart
Cities Challenge and the Canada Infrastructure Bank to manage about $96
billion in funding. It is apparent that the federal government wants to control
which major infrastructure projects will be funded in cities and municipalities
although this is a clearly a provincial jurisdiction.
To see
how our funds are being spent, visit the Infrastructure
Canada funding site.
$42.3
billion in funding covering 48,195 projects has been approved. That is a bit
over 12% of our projected annual budget of $330 billion and we know very little
about exactly where the funds have been spent. That is just over half of the
funds currently allocated.
Samuel de Champlain Bridge |
$42.3
billion is a little more than double our annual federal deficits.
The
spending is unconstitutional meddling in provincial jurisdictions that allows
the federal government to make announcements and appear to be working for
us. We begin to understand how insidious and destructive this regime is.
It is unsurprising that two examples of Infrastructure Canada’s
investments are in the $4 billion Samuel de Champlain Bridge connecting
Montreal with her south shore commuter communities and now the $4.5 billion
Montreal subway extension.
The
federal government is unlawfully using taxpayer funds to buy votes in major
metropolitan centres.
Federal
preoccupation with meddling in provincial affairs to
appear to be leading the nation instead of paying attention to its
responsibilities has to end.
John
Feldsted
Political
Consultant & Strategist
Winnipeg,
Manitoba
Comments
Post a Comment