Skip to main content

“I am a Canadian, free to speak without fear, free to worship in my own way, free to stand for what I think right, free to oppose what I believe wrong, or free to choose those who shall govern my country. This heritage of freedom I pledge to uphold for myself and all mankind.” ~~ John G. Diefenbaker

FELDSTED -- If a breach of ethics, Criminal Code, or federal statutes investigation is underway, investigators must be allowed to seek an Order for government to produce relevant Cabinet materials


As an explanation, this CBC article is an epic fail. First, the Queen’s Privy Council and the Government Cabinet are separate bodies with separate mandates.

The Privy Council provides apolitical advice to the Governor General on what is going on in Government. The Cabinet oversees operations of government departments and agencies. Cabinet ministers are usually members of the Privy Council and their duties vary depending on which body they are attending.

Privy council confidentiality is absolute. Members cannot disclose what is discussed during a privy council meeting. The Clerk of the Privy Council has no authority over the Government Cabinet. It is outside of his jurisdiction.

Cabinet confidentiality is less onerous than Privy Council confidentiality and can be waived by either the Prime Minister or the Courts.

In 1940, Prime Minister Mackenzie King amalgamated the Clerk of the Privy Council and Secretary to the Cabinet into one position reporting to the Prime Minister.

Prior to 1940 the roles were separate, and should be separate today.

Amalgamation causes confusion of the sort highlighted during the SNC-Lavalin affair. The Attorney General and Minister of Justice are separate functions with different responsibilities.     

Justin Trudeau is fairly caught. The Clerk of the Privy Council is not independent; he or she reports to Trudeau. Privy Council confidentiality cannot be applied to Cabinet meetings and material. Trudeau and Privy Council Clerk Ian Shugart can’t hide from their responsibilities.

There is no justification for the confusion.

Separate the roles of the Clerk of the Privy Council, and Secretary to the Cabinet, and Minister of Justice and Attorney General. The media, MPs and the public should not need an index to sort out who they are communicating with.

In past, courts have held that Cabinet confidentiality is important to encourage Cabinet members to speak fully and frankly during meetings. That is fundamental to democracy. These men and women were elected to represent us in government and cannot be censored in what they say or the ideas they put forward.

If there is an investigation underway in respect to a breach of ethics or the Criminal Code or other federal statutes, investigators must be allowed to seek an Order for the government to produce relevant Cabinet materials. The Judge can preview material to ensure that it is relevant to the investigation before releasing it.

The Mark Norman affair is another example of where our government refused to produce documents vital to Mr. Norman's defence and when it had destroyed his career, admitted it did not have case. These who wrongfully charged Mr. Norman need to be brought to justice.

For our Prime Minister to play a game of “Simon Says” with the media, opposition parties and police during an investigation into potential criminal actions is disgusting.

Trudeau must not be allowed to escape accountability.

Our Prime Minister, Cabinet members and Members of Parliament are all accountable to the public.

When our representatives break the law, they must be held accountable. The litany of excuses and evasions we are offered can be expected when petty criminals appear before a court. They are not appropriate in our parliament during an investigation.

None of them are above the law.


The Way I See It ~~ John Feldsted
Political Commentator, Consultant & Strategist
Winnipeg, Manitoba

Labels

Labels:

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

WARD STAMER: “Hopefully he’s actually listening to what people have to say, and not just showing up for a photo op”

In his latest travels across the province, BC Forest Minister Ravi Parmar touched down in the Okanagan. A trip essentially, he said, to be on the ground meeting industry people. I read what he had to say, and about how he has been tasked with getting more timber to market. Let me start by saying, “ He hasn’t been tasked. He and Premier Eby guaranteed 45 million cubic metres of available wood fibre – they guaranteed that .” BC Timber Sales is a government agency within the provincial forest’s ministry, which is responsible for managing a portion of the province's Crown timber; specifically, 20 percent of the province's annual allowable cut. Unfortunately, BC Timber Sales did not provide anywhere near that amount last year, it was just 12.2 percent. Three years ago, BC mills cut 52 million metres of wood, bringing in nearly $2 billion dollars to the provincial treasury. That figure doesn’t include the taxes from 55,700 people directly employed in the industry, nor from the tens o...
Post a Comment
Read more

Conservative Opposition demonstrates focused and policy-oriented approach in first four weeks of the legislative session

In the first four weeks of the legislative session, the Conservative Official Opposition has scored significant policy wins as it proves every day that the Conservative team has fresh ideas and real-world experience to bring to the table. At the same time, the NDP government has been listless, struggling to find a policy agenda that addresses the problems that British Columbians are facing. “This NDP government led by David Eby has tried to do everything under the sun to distract from their disastrous fiscal record and the fact that they are utterly out of ideas,” said Conservative Opposition Leader John Rustad. “They’ve tried to use the U.S. President to deflect from their eye-popping $11 billion deficit, the worst business confidence in the country, and the fact that they’ve created almost zero private sector jobs. This is no way to run a province or an economy.” Since the legislative session started on February 18th with the Throne Speech, the opposition...
Post a Comment
Read more

Conservative Party of BC Calls for Coroner’s Inquest in the Death of Chantelle Williams

  Chantelle Williams/Facebook “Somebody has to come out and tell the truth on what happened and who’s at fault” ~~ Martin Watts, Uncle of Chantelle Williams The Conservative Party of BC is urgently calling for a coroner’s inquest into the death of 18-year-old Indigenous youth Chantelle Williams, who tragically died under the care of Usma Nuu-chah-nulth Family and Child Services, an agency of the Ministry of Children and Family Development. Her family is disturbed by the lack of transparency and unanswered questions surrounding her final moments, and are seeking answers on who was responsible for her care and supervision and why no one noticed she was missing until it was too late. Chantelle was found unresponsive in Port Alberni in the early morning of January 28, 2025. She was later pronounced dead in the hospital. Temperatures had dropped below –7°C the night of her death. Her family is demanding clarity on the circumstances that led to her untimely passing, and they demand answ...
Post a Comment
Read more

Labels

Show more