We,
in Canada have been lucky for years with American governments. Our
trade disputes have been relatively tiny, small, and minimally harmful
over all. To those that did get harmed, it felt like the world was
ending. But if you weren't one of those people you probably never
thought about it.
Today, we are
on notice that almost every Canadian working is now a potential casualty
in a trade war started by Donald Trump. About 78% of all our trade
goes to the United States. That's about $2 billion a day, every day.
Yes, tariffs will hurt American consumers. No one with a brain is going to dispute that.
They will hurt Canadian workers that rely on trade for their jobs a lot worse in the short and medium term.
A
10% tariff as Trump initially proposed would hurt our economy. A 25%
tariff as Trump is now boasting will devastate our economy from coast to
coast to coast, all sectors, all professions.
A recession is guaranteed in this scenario and it will likely be long and deep.
How
does Canada respond? Well, we can put tariffs on American goods but
that would hurt us even more. Our trading relationship with the USA is
not symmetrical. We rely on them far more than they rely on us. They
have a huge advantage in a trade war.
It
is like this. Canada is a small snail on the ground. America is a guy
wearing very large boots. We can't beat the US or even bring them to
heel in a trade war.
Trump is
demanding Canada secure its border with the USA. Note that he's not
demanding that America secure its border. He wants us to shoulder the
cost. He also wants Canada to crack down on Chinese imports that then
go into the US market via our ports. Doug Ford first brought this up in
Canada a couple of weeks ago vis a vis Mexico. Mexican authorities are
already forcing companies to "buy local" parts instead of using Chinese
imports, for example.
If we do
what Trump demands will that fix things? Of course not. Trump will
never be satisfied. Canada and Mexico will always be enemies in his
mind.
Conservatives might say
that Pierre Poilievre will better speak to Trump. Yes, that is a
possibility. Trump does not like Justin Trudeau at all. That's pretty
clear. Hate might be the more appropriate word. But I don't think
Poilievre will have much luck with Trump either.
This
boils down to the simple fact that fascists always need external and
internal enemies to prop up their regimes. Trump cannot make nice with
an enemy unless he has a good replacement. He needs the enemy, closer
the better, to keep his base in a state of agitation.
What
about CUSMA? Don't we have a trade agreement? As the CBC article shows, Trump is all but tearing up an agreement he signed with us. The
treaty will be null and void and there's nothing we can do about that.
What
about the World Trade Organization or WTO? Can they intervene? The UN
and the WTO is a UN body operates through agreements and negotiation.
When you have an irrational fascist in one country tearing up agreements
it should be clear he won't care what WTO or anyone else says.
Okay,
is there any good news? Well, there is a good chance what Trump said
yesterday may never happen or not as extreme. Cooler heads in his
administration, and there are a few, might get him to scale this stuff
back. Congress may intervene as much as they can because they have a
lot of members that are in states relying on that stable trade
relationship.
I think the best
bet on mitigating this impending disaster are American consumer groups.
They have huge voice in the US. Americans don't like paying more for
the things in life they both need and want. When prices go up, and
inflation spikes, Trump and his administration will be facing an epic
backlash.
Of course, that might take time.
One thing is certain, 2025 is going to be off to a very bad start
" For far too long, the BC NDP has ignored the economic challenges facing British Columbians. Manufacturing jobs are vanishing, forestry is in decline, and private sector employment growth has stagnated. Meanwhile, affordability has worsened for both families and businesses. British Columbians deserve better, and we’re here to deliver real solutions to rebuild our economy and create jobs that support everyday working people and their families ." – Gavin Dew, MLA and Shadow Minister for Jobs, Economy, Development, and Innovation. December 3, 2024, Vancouver, BC – The Conservative economic team met today with business leaders and stakeholders to tackle critical issues impacting British Columbia’s economy. Attended by 9 critics from the Conservative Caucus, this meeting was convened by MLA Gavin Dew – Shadow Minister for Jobs, Economic Development, and Innovation - as a direct response to an October 30th open letter from seven of the province’s largest industry associations. ...
Comments
Post a Comment