Skip to main content

“I am a Canadian, free to speak without fear, free to worship in my own way, free to stand for what I think right, free to oppose what I believe wrong, or free to choose those who shall govern my country. This heritage of freedom I pledge to uphold for myself and all mankind.” ~~ John G. Diefenbaker

So am I a Canadian … or a hyphenated Canadian? And if hyphenated Canadian, am I Canadian first or second?


I find it interesting to note, given all of the recent hypocrisy about racial intolerance, the words to the national anthem of our country.



O Canada!
Our home and native land!
True patriot love

In all thy sons command.
With glowing hearts

We see thee rise,
The True North strong and free!
From far and wide,
O Canada,

We stand on guard for thee.
God keep
our land

Glorious and free!
O Canada,
we stand on guard for thee.
O Canada,
we stand on guard for thee.





The ONLY words used to describe the people of Canada are …. OUR … and WE.  “Our” being the people of this country … and “We” as the group, or collection, of the entire population.  No where in the words to OUR national anthem do I see WE being a collection of hyphenated Canadians – at least not where hyphenated we are Canadian second.



The 2016 Census of Population questions, long form (National Household Survey), asked a number of questions around our ethnic backgrounds. They included:
#17  What are the ethnic, or cultural, origins of this person’s ancestors.

For example, Canadian, English, Chinese, French, East Indian, Italian, German, Scottish, Cree, Mi'kmaq, Salish, Métis, Inuit, Filipino, Irish, Dutch, Ukrainian, Polish, Portuguese, Vietnamese, Korean, Jamaican, Greek, Iranian, Lebanese, Mexican, Somali, Colombian, etc.



#19  Is this person:

White, South Asian (East Indian, Pakistani, Sri Lankan, etc.), Chinese, Black, Filipino, Latin American, Arab, Southeast Asian (Vietnamese, Cambodian, Laotian, Thai, etc.), West Asian (Iranian, Afghan, etc.), Korean, Japanese, Other (please specify)



Note, the very first option to question #17 is whether my ethnic background is Canadian.  Now don’t get me wrong, there is nothing wrong with asking (or knowing) what the ethnic backgrounds of our country are.  Over the decades we have become a rich colourful fabric woven of many backgrounds … from all over the world.  It seems to me however, that Prime Minister Justin Trudeau, is bound and determined to wipe out any choice of being simply a Canadian.




So, am I a Canadian … or a hyphenated Canadian?  And if hyphenated Canadian, am I Canadian first or second?  For example, a Canadian of Italian descent … OR … an Italian–Canadian.  In my opinion, I live in Canada … I am a Canadian, therefore I am a Canadian of Italian descent. 



Question 19, at least in my opinion, runs the risk of setting up stronger ethnic bounds, rather than identifying as a Canadian first, and secondly of whatever proud heritage we may have.



John Diefenbaker, our countries 13th Prime Minister said, "I have one love - Canada; one purpose - Canada's greatness; one aim - Canadian unity from the Atlantic to the Pacific."



He also said, "I am the first Prime Minister of this country of neither altogether English nor French origin. So, I determined to bring about a Canadian citizenship that knew no hyphenated consideration."



However, our Prime Minister, Justin Trudeau, believes, “There is no core identity, no mainstream in Canada



Which is likely brought about the recent Twitter wars, with a gang-up, by some, on Maxime Bernier.  He was right – he is right – in what he has said over the past few days on this topic of a Canadian identity, and it’s diversity!



Trudeau’s extreme multiculturalism and cult of diversity will divide us into little tribes that have less and less in common



More diversity will not be our strength, it will destroy what has made us such a great country.”



Which again leads back to what type of hyphenated Canadian we will be.  Because “… identity politics simply panders to another group to be bought off with promises, generally never kept!



Maxime Bernier went on to also say: “Identity politics has become pervasive and is being practiced by all political parties trying to buy votes. Political debate has degenerated into a contest between different ways of pandering to specific groups instead of appealing to our common interests.”



Canadian citizens have rights and responsibilities, and they come to us from our history.  They are secured by Canadian law… and they reflect our shared traditions, identity, and values. And, according to the government of Canada, our Rights and Responsibilities as Canadian citizens include the protection of our Multicultural make-up.  Our multi-culturalism is a fundamental characteristic of the Canadian heritage and identity. Canadians celebrate the gift of one another’s presence and work hard to respect pluralism and live in harmony.



John Diefenbaker had it partially right when he said, “I determined to bring about a Canadian citizenship that knew no hyphenated consideration."

Hyphenated Canadians, YES … but second after FIRST being a Canadian.  We as Canadians do have a core identify, it’s that our country was, and is, made up of a rich fabric of people from all walks of life.  And we should, and do celebrate that rich diversity.

Despite what Prime Minister Justin Trudeau may say, that IS what is mainstream in Canada.  Which brings me back to what I started with, and the words of our National Anthem:



The ONLY words used to describe the people of Canada are …. OUR … and WE.  “Our” being the people of this country … and “We” as the group, or collection, of the entire population.  No where in the words to OUR national anthem do I see WE being a collection of hyphenated Canadians – at least not where we are Canadian second.



The late Stompin’ Tom Connors may have said it best, in the song Believe in YourCountry:



If you don’t believe your country,

Should come before yourself

You can better serve your country

By living somewhere else





In Kamloops, I’m Alan Forseth.  I am a proud Canadian, and a muddle of ethnicities from Scandinavian, Saskatchewan Plains Indian, Scottish, Italian, and heaven knows what else.  And I am proud my forebears decided to make Canada their home.

Comments

  1. Cultural diversity is only valuable when cultures respect one another and work together for the common good of our communities, provinces and country. When cultural groups compete for power and prestige, democracy is at risk and civil war is on the horizon.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Good article, Al.
    I once got a detention in school for answering "Canadian" to a question of origin. At that time it wasn't even an option. Lol. To this day I refuse to answer anything but Canadian. I am proud of my family's background and my heritage. As everyone else should be too. I am always delighted and enriched when someone cares enough to share their heritage with me. We are all immigrants, even the indigenous peoples came here for a better life long ago. And, I love when they share their heritage. Together, we are the "we" of our national anthem. Together we determine our future.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thanks for taking the time to comment Dave, and for sharing what I believe are the sentiments of most Canadians!

      Delete
  3. Bravo ! And thank you.

    ReplyDelete
  4. Even if this ethnic identity thing were true there are plenty of things people define themselves by besides their racial / ethnic heritage. I'm a father, I'm a man of faith, I'm a small businessman, I vote for ____ party. As for ethnicity is the Irish part of me supposed to hate the English side or the French the German side? Is the Polish side of my wife supposed to hate the German side of me? (some days I wonder) My point is that ethnicity alone does not define who I am or how I vote and you sell me and most of the Canadian population short if you think it does.

    ReplyDelete

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

GORDON F. D. WILSON: When The Trick Masquerades as The Treat

Thirty-seven years ago, Halloween 1987, I became the leader of the BC Liberal Party.   British Columbia was badly polarized. Social Credit held one side and the NDP the other. It had been twelve years, 1975, since Liberal MLAs Garde Gardom, Pat McGeer, and Alan Williams had walked away from their party to join Social Credit, one year after the lone Progressive Conservative MLA Hugh Curtis had abandoned his party to sit with Bill Bennett, the son and heir apparent to long-serving BC Premier, WAC Bennett.   An unwritten agreement by the biggest Canadian political shareholders, the federal Liberals and Conservatives, decided that if British Columbia was to remain a lucrative franchise from a revenue perspective, they couldn’t risk splitting the electoral vote and electing the real enemy, the NDP, so no resources would be used to finance either a Liberal or Conservative party provincially.   “There are two sides to every street,” I was told by a very prominent Canadian businessman who cont

FORSETH: You Have To Be A Bit Crazy

  Ward and his wife Carleen celebrating his win on election night.   In March of this year, I took on the role of Campaign Manager for BC Conservative candidate Ward Stamer.  It’s the third time I’ve had the opportunity as I took on the role for Peter Sharp in 2013, and for Dennis Giesbrecht in 2020. Now let me tell you, in the past, a BC Conservative campaign team generally consisted of myself, the candidate and one or two helpers – and very little in the way of a campaign budget. Thankfully, a benefit of having spent 30+ years in the broadcast media afforded me the ability to do ad copy and write candidate speeches, and prep both Dennis and Peter to deal with the media – it’s also something I have always enjoyed. That was part of my duties this time around as well, however having a team of a dozen and a half volunteers meant that for the first time we had people available to ID our supporters, put together and install campaign signs, distribute campaign literature, and help out at ou

Rustad will support policy for 'everyday' people, otherwise work to bring down NDP

  Conservative Party of B.C. John Rustad Tuesday (Oct. 29) said his party would support government policies that support "average, everyday working" persons in B.C., but also repeated earlier promises to bring down the B.C. NDP government under Premier David Eby. "If there are things that are moved forward that will improve lives for those people, we would be looking at support it," Rustad said. "But if he's going to carry forward with the destructive policies that he has, then yes, we are going to look at every opportunity possible to bring him down as soon as possible."  CLICK HERE for the full story

Labels

Show more