Skip to main content

“I am a Canadian, free to speak without fear, free to worship in my own way, free to stand for what I think right, free to oppose what I believe wrong, or free to choose those who shall govern my country. This heritage of freedom I pledge to uphold for myself and all mankind.” ~~ John G. Diefenbaker

TRAVEL RESTRICTIONS? We can impose restrictions on people travelling ... how practical are they ... we can’t prevent people from travelling ... we will not be imposing travel restrictions ... what do we do, arrest them?"


Don't feel bad if you're confused when it come to clarity around COVID-19 travel restrictions. The following is a list, provided by the BC Liberal Party, of conflicting quotations regarding travel restrictions from Premier John Horgan, and Health Minister Adrian Dix. This is followed by quotations on the matter from stakeholders such as the police.

 

John Horgan 

• “Legal advice is what we’ve sought and we’ll take a look at it over the next couple of days… I want to put this either to rest so that BCers understand that we cannot do that, and we’re not going to do that, or there is a way to do it and we’re going to work with other provinces to achieve it.” – John Horgan, January 10, 2021 (Source: Vancouver Sun, April 15, 2021) 

• “The review of our legal options made it clear we can’t prevent people from travelling to British Columbia. We can impose restrictions on people travelling for non-essential purposes if they are causing harm to the health and safety of British Columbians. Much of current interprovincial travel is work related and therefore cannot be restricted.” – John Horgan, News Release, January 21, 2021 

• “Public health officials tell us what is most important is for everyone to obey health orders, wherever they are, rather than imposing mobility rules. Therefore, we will not be imposing travel restrictions at this time.” – John Horgan, News Release, January 21, 2021 

• “There is a very good point. The travel issue has been bedevilling me from the beginning… Very challenging to put up checkpoints. That has not happened at any other part of the country.  There was a bubble in the Maritimes and that is easier to do -- smaller populations, fewer roads to cover -- but it would be very difficult here.” – John Horgan, CFAX, April 7, 2021 

• "But what do we do? Arrest them?" – John Horgan, CBC On the Island, April 7, 2021 

• “I appreciate we want to be like New Zealand, but we can't be.” – John Horgan, CBC On the Island, April 7, 2021 

• “We haven't taken travel restrictions off the board, quite frankly. It's about how practical are they and how can we enforce.” – John Horgan, CBC, April 13, 2021 

• “This will be conducted through random audits, not unlike roadside checks...” – John Horgan, April 19, 2021 Press Conference 

• “…everybody who goes by will be asked where they're going [and] where they came from.” - John Horgan, April 19, 2021 Press Conference 

 

• “[Police checkpoints that would apply to] …all vehicles over a period of time on a piece of highway somewhere in British Columbia” - John Horgan, April 19, 2021 Press Conference 

• “[The Minister of Public Safety] will be using the Emergency Program Act, to restrict people’s ability to move from one health authority to another… it will be done in a way that includes everyone …And there will be consequences if you are outside of your area on non-essential business.” – John Horgan, April 19, 2021 Press Conference 


Adrian Dix 

• “We can't have armies of people enforcing those rules. We're asking people.” – Adrian Dix, News 1130, April 6, 2021

• “We need a ferry system and the idea that we could shut it down or dramatically limit it I think wouldn’t be in the interests of Vancouver Island.” – Adrian Dix, CBC On the Island, April 16, 2021 

• “Some people say, well, you can close the border or put up border restrictions. We've got a large border, and practically speaking, we're one country.” – Adrian Dix, CBC Vancouver, April 16, 2021 

• “Some of these measures like closing provincial borders, the provincial border like we have, we’re in one country after all, are simply not practical to put in place.” – Adrian Dix, CBC  Daybreak Kamloops, April 16, 2021 

• Cragie: “Why not bring in more restrictions this week?” 

Dix: “The most important restrictions are the ones we have in place now.” – Adrian Dix, CBC On  the Island, April 16, 2021 


Stakeholders 

• “Participating in enforcement road-blocks puts even greater pressure on limited resources." - National Police Federation  

• "The VPD is not conducting random checks for compliance with travel restrictions. We have not seen specific details of these pending restrictions." - Vancouver Police Department  

• “We would certainly ask that the government make us a priority for vaccination before they start asking us to start enforcing their public health orders.” - New Westminster Police Officers Association 
 

• “The lack of information and details about the order has raised many alarm bells, especially in the middle of a global and local reckoning about systemic racism in policing and policing powers  – Joint letter of 11 organizations and societies 

• “Police do not have the legal authority to ask questions like…Where are you going? Where are you coming from? For what purpose?” - BC Civil Liberties Association

Labels:

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Nurses Take Job Action After Years of NDP Neglect

Image Credit:  BC Nurses Union BC nurses have reached a breaking point after years of unsafe conditions, rising violence in the workplace and a government that wouldn’t listen. Now they are on the picket line fighting to be heard. Last week, nurses began job action with a 72-hour strike notice, refusing non-essential overtime and stepping back from non-nursing duties. As of Tuesday, they have escalated to picket lines for the first time in decades. This moment was avoidable. It is the result of years of unanswered concerns from the frontline workers who keep our hospitals running. Nurses have been raising the same concerns for years: unsafe staffing levels, rising violence on the job, and a workload no single person should have to carry. None of it is new, and none of it should have taken a strike vote to get the government's attention. "Nurses are exercising their legal right to job action, but it shouldn’t have had to come to this," said Kiel Giddens, MLA for...
Post a Comment
Read more

British Columbians Still Don’t Know Who’s Paying for NDP’s BC Hydro Deal

The NDP is making billion-dollar promises with BC Hydro, but British Columbians still don’t know who will pay the bill. Last week’s memorandum of understanding isn’t what the federal government and the NDP are making it out to be. It’s an admission that the NDP failed to make the long-term investments needed to keep B.C. powered. Now British Columbians have serious questions about the cost and whether BC Hydro ratepayers will end up paying the price. David L. Williams, MLA for Salmon Arm-Shuswap and Shadow Minister for BC Hydro and Electrical Energy Development , said British Columbians deserve clear answers about the full implications of the Canada–British Columbia Cooperative Prosperity Agreement. “British Columbians deserve the full truth,” said Mr. Williams. “This multi-billion-dollar announcement does not answer who pays for cost overruns, who pays for new generation, who carries the risk if industrial customers do not materialize, or whether ratepayers will be forced ...
Post a Comment
Read more

NDP Government Blames Everyone but Themselves

The federal government has announced new measures to support British Columbia's forestry sector, including $65 million in funding for projects across the province. While any support is welcome, it falls far short of the level of assistance other provinces have secured for key industries. Conservative Forests Critic Ward Stamer says the NDP government needs to take responsibility for its mismanagement of B.C.’s forest industry instead of trying to pass on the blame. Despite promising to create more jobs in the forest sector, the NDP government has overseen the loss of thousands of forestry jobs and 21 mill closures which have devastated communities. “If Premier Eby spent more time addressing the regulatory issues impacting the forestry sector than he did complaining about the federal government, we would not be in the position we are now,” said Stamer. “And instead of trying to place the blame for mill closures on Donald Trump, Minister of Forests Ravi Parmar should t...
Post a Comment
Read more

Labels

Show more