Skip to main content

“I am a Canadian, free to speak without fear, free to worship in my own way, free to stand for what I think right, free to oppose what I believe wrong, or free to choose those who shall govern my country. This heritage of freedom I pledge to uphold for myself and all mankind.” ~~ John G. Diefenbaker

FRASER INSTITUTE -- The Trudeau government acts like it has a majority mandate and extensive powers to spend and borrow at will -- without meaningful parliamentary oversight


Next week, the Trudeau government will deliver an economic “snapshot” of federal finances and expectations for the next few months, although stopping well short of a full budget or economic update.

 

The prime minister’s rationale, echoed by the finance minister, is that the economic environment is too volatile for the government to reasonably estimate its finances over anything longer than a few months. This is unacceptable and shows once again that this federal government is operating with little regard for democratic accountability.

 

Remember, the Liberals didn’t earn a majority mandate from voters last election. In fact, they actually finished second in the popular vote, behind the Conservatives—the Liberals had 5.91 million votes (33.1 per cent) versus 6.15 million votes for the Conservatives (34.4 per cent). The Liberal share of the popular vote is the lowest for any party forming government in Canadian history.

 

And yet the Trudeau government acts like it has a majority mandate and extensive powers to spend and borrow at will without meaningful parliamentary oversight.

 

The government is able to function without a budget due in part to legislation (Bill C-13) passed in March that provides the government power to spend and borrow without parliamentary approval until September 2020. Indeed, the government originally wanted unlimited taxing abilities in addition to the spending and borrowing powers—and a longer timeline. Clearly, the government’s refusal to publish a full economic update calls into question the efficacy of its authority.

 

In reality, a number of financial developments over the last few months require full transparency and detailed cost estimates. Consider, for instance, that the Parliamentary Budget Officer (PBO) now projects a deficit of at least $250 billion, with total federal debt quickly approaching $1 trillion.

 

The PBO also projects marked increases in the cost of some programs. For example, the Canada Emergency Response Benefit (CERB) is now estimated to cost $61.1 billion (before tax recoveries) compared to the original estimate of $40.6 billion. And economists have raised questions about the number of CERB recipients compared to the number of Canadians receiving wage subsidies or employment insurance benefits.

 

Moreover, consider that a number of provinces including Saskatchewan and Prince Edward Island have updated their finances and released budgets in this environment, as have other countries. For example, New Zealand produced a budget in mid-May that provided several hundred pages of detail about its fiscal and economic projections for the next five years.

 

Given the federal department of finance’s vast resources, which include a $1.6 billion department budget, an entire division dedicated to fiscal policy (i.e. tax and spending policies) and a plethora of experienced bureaucrats, it’s hard to justify the Trudeau government’s position that it can’t deliver a budget or at the very least an economic update.

 

Past federal governments released budgets during both world wars and during the pronounced recessions in 1982 and 2009.

 

In other words, other governments, both past and present, have managed to remain accountable to the public by producing detailed economic and fiscal projections during uncertain times.

 

The Trudeau government should follow their example and promptly deliver a budget, or at least an economic update.

 

 

AUTHORS:
Jason Clemens, Executive Vice President, Fraser Institute

Jake Fuss, Economist, Fraser Institute

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

FORSETH -- If having three un-happy MLA’s leave the party, is what it takes to have unity within caucus, then I say, “Fine; let it be so”

Regrettably, in recent days, issues within the Conservative Party of BC have come to the surface resulting in one member being removed from Caucus (Dallas Brodie) and the party, and two others (Tara Armstrong and Jordan Kealy) leaving of their own accord. As of this morning (Saturday March 8th) all three are now sitting as independents in the BC legislature. So, what does that mean? In the last twenty-four hours social media feeds have lit up with support for leader John Rustad, while others have been negative, accusing the party, and Rustad, of being bullies and not standing up for conservative values. Ryan Painter, who has personally worked with John Rustad, had this to say: Since the beginning, he's had one target: the BC NDP. He knows that British Columbians deserve a government that works for them, delivers on their promises, and doesn't tax them into poverty. He believes in his team and the power of a focused opposition. He knows who the enemy is. He knows BC deserves ...

WARD STAMER: “Hopefully he’s actually listening to what people have to say, and not just showing up for a photo op”

In his latest travels across the province, BC Forest Minister Ravi Parmar touched down in the Okanagan. A trip essentially, he said, to be on the ground meeting industry people. I read what he had to say, and about how he has been tasked with getting more timber to market. Let me start by saying, “ He hasn’t been tasked. He and Premier Eby guaranteed 45 million cubic metres of available wood fibre – they guaranteed that .” BC Timber Sales is a government agency within the provincial forest’s ministry, which is responsible for managing a portion of the province's Crown timber; specifically, 20 percent of the province's annual allowable cut. Unfortunately, BC Timber Sales did not provide anywhere near that amount last year, it was just 12.2 percent. Three years ago, BC mills cut 52 million metres of wood, bringing in nearly $2 billion dollars to the provincial treasury. That figure doesn’t include the taxes from 55,700 people directly employed in the industry, nor from the tens o...

Conservative Opposition demonstrates focused and policy-oriented approach in first four weeks of the legislative session

In the first four weeks of the legislative session, the Conservative Official Opposition has scored significant policy wins as it proves every day that the Conservative team has fresh ideas and real-world experience to bring to the table. At the same time, the NDP government has been listless, struggling to find a policy agenda that addresses the problems that British Columbians are facing. “This NDP government led by David Eby has tried to do everything under the sun to distract from their disastrous fiscal record and the fact that they are utterly out of ideas,” said Conservative Opposition Leader John Rustad. “They’ve tried to use the U.S. President to deflect from their eye-popping $11 billion deficit, the worst business confidence in the country, and the fact that they’ve created almost zero private sector jobs. This is no way to run a province or an economy.” Since the legislative session started on February 18th with the Throne Speech, the opposition...

Labels

Show more