Skip to main content

“I am a Canadian, free to speak without fear, free to worship in my own way, free to stand for what I think right, free to oppose what I believe wrong, or free to choose those who shall govern my country. This heritage of freedom I pledge to uphold for myself and all mankind.” ~~ John G. Diefenbaker

Conservatives: "The NDP said what about DRIPA? "

Scott Fraser was the Minister of Indigenous Relations and Reconciliation in the government of the late Premier John Horgan


After the BC Court of Appeal 2-to-1 decision in support of Gitxaala Nation and Ehattesaht First Nation, which affirmed that courts have a duty to view and measure B.C. laws through the lens of DRIPA, Premier David Eby is desperately trying to change the channel on how this law could drastically impact investment and economic certainty in British Columbia.

It's a far cry from what the previous Minister of Indigenous Relations and Reconciliation (Scott Fraser) said in the house about how DRIPA would have no force or effect.

THE NDP insisted DRIPA would not impact private property rights or have sweeping legal consequences. Their previous Minister of Indigenous Relations and Reconciliations’ own words are now meaningless:


Quotes from 2019 Debate

“The legislation sees us bring provincial laws into harmony with the UN declaration over time.” – Scott Fraser, Hansard, Oct 10/24


No Force and Effect

“I stated earlier that Bill 41 doesn’t give the UN declaration itself the force of law and doesn’t create any new laws and new rights.  That’s inclusive of private land.” – Scott Fraser, Hansard Nov 25/19


“There are no new rights created within this bill, within Bill 41, but it does affirm the rights within section 35, jurisprudence.” – Scott Fraser, Hansard, Nov 21/19


“With the passage of this bill, this will be, still, an interpretive tool. Bill 41 brings no legal force and effect to the UN declaration.” – Scott Fraser, Hansard, Nov 19/19


“I’ll just repeat. There’s no legal force in effect.” – Scott Fraser, Hansard, Nov 20/19


Interpretive Aid

“The courts may look to the declaration as an interpretive aid — where if there’s ambiguity in legislation such that there’s an interpretation that aligns better with the declaration, that interpretation would be preferred.” – Scott Fraser, Hansard, Nov 26/19


“It’s dealing with the idea that the courts could still….There’s nothing in this act that would prevent the courts from using the UN declaration, as they can already, as an interpretive tool.” – Scott Fraser, Hansard, Nov 19/19


Not a veto

“It is not a switch that will change every statute and process in the government the day after this act is proclaimed, nor is it a veto over development.” – Scott Fraser, Hansard, Oct 30/19

 

Labels:

Comments

  1. Chris CDecember 8, 2025 at 10:05 AM

    It didn't create new rights. Aboriginal title is an existing right, affirmed under section 35 of the Constitution. Aboriginal title exists in Canadian law and the courts have constantly said that the onus is on governments to work together to clarify what those rights mean. The courts have not ever wanted to be the ones to define those rights, but if governments won't negotiate, what choice to First Nations have to get clarity on Aboriginal title? That doesn't mean that we don't have to work out how those rights and title issues work together, but DRIPA did not create new rights in British Columbia. Nothing has superseded Constitutional rights.

    ReplyDelete

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Abbotsford-Mission MLA Reann Gasper to step down for Conservative Leader Hon. Kerry-Lynne Findlay to run in a by-election

Deputy Whip and MLA Reann Gasper has informed the Speaker of the Legislative Assembly of British Columbia of her decision to step down as MLA for Abbotsford-Mission, creating an opportunity for Conservative Party of British Columbia Leader Hon. Kerry-Lynne Findlay to seek the seat in a forthcoming by-election. Gasper said the decision was made carefully and deliberately, with the future of British Columbia firmly in mind. Abbotsford-Mission MLA Reann Gasper “This is a decision I have made after a great deal of careful consideration, and I believe it is the right decision for me, for our Party, and for the work ahead,” said MLA Gasper. “It has been a privilege to represent the people of Abbotsford-Mission, and I am deeply grateful to everyone who placed their trust in me. I am also grateful for the opportunity to serve alongside my colleagues in the Conservative Caucus and to contribute to our leadership team.” “I have confidence in Kerry-Lynne, in her leadership, and in her ability to ...
Post a Comment
Read more

NDP Sits on $61 Million With No Start Date for Burnaby Hospital

Phase 2 of Burnaby Hospital redevelopment  was green lit to go ahead in September 2023 The NDP spent $45 million on the Burnaby Hospital redevelopment, cancelled the second phase, and now has another $61 million listed for the project in the province’s Public Accounts, with no start date for construction. If the NDP cancelled the project, what is happening to the $61 million set aside for it? The Phase 2 project was expected to cost between $1.7 billion and $1.8 billion and was intended to expand the hospital’s capacity. With Burnaby’s population growing and residents struggling to access healthcare, the government should be investing in healthcare capacity, not leaving millions of dollars tied up in limbo. “The NDP spent $45 million on this project before cancelling it, and now $61 million remains listed for it in the Public Accounts,” said MLA Misty Van Popta, Shadow Minister for Infrastructure. “If the government isn’t going to build the hospital expansion, it should explain whe...
Post a Comment
Read more

BC Conservatives Point to Warning Signs in BC’s Economy

While Canada posted modest job gains in July, warning lights are still flashing in British Columbia. Youth unemployment remains stubbornly high, leaving too many first-time jobseekers shut out of the workforce. BC also lost 3,400 public administration jobs in July, likely as temporary Census positions ended. “BC's jobs divide remains stark. Unemployment is far higher in business-driven communities like Kelowna (9.3%) and Abbotsford-Mission (8.3%) than in Victoria (5.0%). Government should be focused on creating the conditions for private-sector investment and job growth,” said Gavin Dew, MLA for Kelowna-Mission and Shadow Minister for Economic Development. “We need an economy where young people can find work, businesses can hire, and every region has the opportunity to prosper.” This comes as BC faces five straight quarters where more businesses are closing than opening, an NDP cabinet rift over job-creating projects like Tilbury LNG, and fresh signs that even the province's to...
Post a Comment
Read more

Labels

Show more