Skip to main content

“I am a Canadian, free to speak without fear, free to worship in my own way, free to stand for what I think right, free to oppose what I believe wrong, or free to choose those who shall govern my country. This heritage of freedom I pledge to uphold for myself and all mankind.” ~~ John G. Diefenbaker

FELDSTED: The idea that solitary confinement is always a form of punishment is simply not true


Liberals set to amend solitary confinement rules in wake of dual court calls for action
Amanda Connolly ~~ National Online Journalist / Global News ~~ October 15, 2018

Canada’s Minister of Public Safety and
Emergency Preparedness, Ralph Goodale,
is the MP for the Regina- Wascana riding
The federal Liberals are set to introduce a new bill tackling the issue of administrative segregation, more commonly known as solitary confinement.  A bill was put on the notice paper on Oct. 11, which is how the government gives notice that it intends to table legislation in the House of Commons…

… it is not clear at this time what new limits or bans the new bill could put in place on the use of solitary confinement.

The federal government introduced a bill in June 2017 … however, that bill never made it past first reading and has wallowed in legislative purgatory ever since… a series of legal challenges that came after it have resulted in court rulings that strict limits are needed and that using solitary confinement long-term is unconstitutional.

A government official …  acknowledged there have been concerns raised repeatedly by justice advocates over the last year and a half that the language in the existing bill does not fully address the concerns raised in two significant court rulings that have come since.

… an Ontario Superior Court judge also deemed the long-term use of solitary confinement in federal prisons unconstitutional.

He called for much stricter limits of no more than five days in order to prevent psychological harm to the offender.

To read full story CLICK HERE:

I don’t suppose the jurors have ever considered that they are not legislators, or that prisoners are not the most reliable judges of what constitutes psychological abuse.

Some prisoners are isolated due to their crimes; for example, child molesters are unlikely to survive in general population and will be most likely be killed. Others are in debt from gambling, or from illicit drug use, and will meet an untimely death if not protected.


Then there are the psychopaths who gain separation by attacking and harming other inmates. We also have dangerous criminals who will not hesitate to murder again. Once they are sentences to life without parole for 25 years, they have little to lose, and are thus more dangerous than most.

There is considerable difference between provincial jails, where convicted persons serve sentences less than two years, and federal prisons where convicted persons serve sentences of two years or more. That is where the sentencing term “two years less a day” comes from – the judge is deciding to send a convicted person to a provincial jail rather than a federal prison.

The proposed legislation has numerous unintended consequences, and if passed will see some lives lost when prison officials are required to release an inmate from solitary confinement. The idea that solitary confinement is always a form of punishment is simply not true.

There are instances where tempers flare, a fight breaks out and combatants are temporarily confined to allow tempers to cool, and second thoughts to rule. Those confined are likely to consider the confinement to be punishment, but without intervention and serious harm taking place, one of the combatants would face assault charges and most likely an extension of his sentence.

Others, as cited above, will kill or be killed with whatever devices are available. It will not be humane or pretty. Of course, judges never have to deal with a prisoner stabbed multiple times with home-made knives, or strangled with an appliance cord, or gang raped, or simply beaten to death.

This is a case where ideology and reality clash and pushing ideology will have dire consequences.


John Feldsted
Political Consultant & Strategist
Winnipeg, Manitoba
Labels:

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Okanagan Farmers Face NDP-Created Water Crisis ~~ BC Conservatives

Okanagan farmers are facing a water crisis as government-imposed restrictions threaten to kill their crops and destroy one of B.C.’s most important agricultural industries. In perhaps the most water-rich province in the country, our farmers have been left high and dry by the NDP government. For nine weeks, Okanagan and Shuswap farmers have proposed solutions, only to be met with NDP foot-dragging. Now forest fires have come to these regions as they are simultaneously reckoning with a water crisis that has been made worse through years of government inaction. Vernon-area farms have lost 70 percent of their water, while Kelowna and Summerland growers face severe restrictions. This situation is unacceptable and cannot continue. Ian Paton, Shadow Minister for Agriculture, said the NDP is once again forcing farmers to pay for its own failure to plan. "Farmers and ranchers must be listened to when decisions affecting their livelihoods are made, and under the NDP, they aren’t," said...
Post a Comment
Read more

BC Conservatives Point to Warning Signs in BC’s Economy

While Canada posted modest job gains in July, warning lights are still flashing in British Columbia. Youth unemployment remains stubbornly high, leaving too many first-time jobseekers shut out of the workforce. BC also lost 3,400 public administration jobs in July, likely as temporary Census positions ended. “BC's jobs divide remains stark. Unemployment is far higher in business-driven communities like Kelowna (9.3%) and Abbotsford-Mission (8.3%) than in Victoria (5.0%). Government should be focused on creating the conditions for private-sector investment and job growth,” said Gavin Dew, MLA for Kelowna-Mission and Shadow Minister for Economic Development. “We need an economy where young people can find work, businesses can hire, and every region has the opportunity to prosper.” This comes as BC faces five straight quarters where more businesses are closing than opening, an NDP cabinet rift over job-creating projects like Tilbury LNG, and fresh signs that even the province's to...
Post a Comment
Read more

FORSETH: That, to me, sure seems to fit with narcissistic personality disorder – AND - a definite sense of self entitlement

I think most people are aware of why England’s Henry the 8th created the Church of England. It was out of a belief that he should be able to do anything he wanted. And what did he want?  It was a male heir that would follow him and, at his death, become the next King of England.   His marriage to Catherine had not produced one, so he demanded the Pope to allow him to divorce her.  The Pope of course refused so Henry created his own church, and declared himself the "Supreme Head of the Church of England", thereby allowing him to annul the marriage. In other words, he wanted his own way, and because he had the ultimate power in England, he forced his will over the church. Many (most?) would say people suffer like that from 'narcissistic personality disorder'. The Mayo Clinic says, “ People with this disorder may lack the ability to understand or care about the feelings of others. But behind this mask of extreme confidence, they are not sure of their self-worth and are e...
5 comments
Read more

Labels

Show more