Skip to main content

“I am a Canadian, free to speak without fear, free to worship in my own way, free to stand for what I think right, free to oppose what I believe wrong, or free to choose those who shall govern my country. This heritage of freedom I pledge to uphold for myself and all mankind.” ~~ John G. Diefenbaker

While the BC government states that, removing impediments to trade create a safer and more dependable business environment for investors, interprovincial trade remains tangled in protectionism


In just 29 words (Constitution Act Section 121) the Fathers of Confederation managed to state that:
 "All Articles of the Growth, Produce, or Manufacture of any one of the Provinces shall, from and after the Union, be admitted free into each of the other Provinces."

And as the Huffington Post commented:
How beautifully succinct; how pellucidly clear. No need for clumsy jargon about "growing the economy," gauzy "visions for promoting trade," or cross-fingered promises of "working groups" to "explore opportunities." And the best part: it's already part of the supreme law of the land.

Year after year after year however, both provincial and federal politicians have huffed and puffed about removing inter-provincial trade barriers.  Still 150 years later we have yet to see, or find, one news story announcing an end to these barriers.

We in Canada’s two most westerly provinces (British Columbia and Alberta) approve by a majority of over 60% the removal of barriers to freer trade between provinces ... not surprisingly, protectionist Quebec has residents at the lowest end, with just 43% agreeing to lowering of trade restrictions.  The +60% figure for British Columbia makes sense given we are
a trading province, and as the BC government stated last September, this is especially important considering that about 40% of Canada’s trade takes place within its own borders.

Two stories from CBC News seemed to capture things rather succinctly however, when it comes to the lack of headway on breaking down barriers:

Canadians, after all, can't be allowed to just run around Canada willy-nilly, buying whatever they want ... is there any economic good in them (our interprovincial trade barriers) ... "No. The answer is no." (Daniel Schwanen, at the C.D. Howe Institute)

CBC NEWS ... July 16th, 2018
Everyone loves to talk about interprovincial trade - but tangible progress is scarce ... all the provincial and territorial trade ministers were given a symbolic pair of golden scissors to remind them to start cutting interprovincial trade barriers ... the trouble is, they aren't using them.

So, what is happening? 

Not a damn thing really.

While the federal government continues to work on negotiating international free trade agreements ... we have yet to see headway being made here in our own country.  That, despite agreement that it needs to happen.  Here in British Columbia a government news story from last fall (Sept 10th) indicated that:

“Improving the flow of goods and services helps to create a strong and diverse economy, allowing B.C. companies to grow their business and create good jobs and opportunities in every corner of the province.”

Still, just two and a half months ago the Vancouver Sun brought us this ridiculous statement
... examples of Canadian companies finding it easier to import goods and services internationally than trading with their neighbouring provinces are far too plentiful — and frequently absurd ...

Someone however, seems to be attempting to restart discussions on freer inter-provincial trade.


At the end of February, Manitoba Premier Brian Pallister commented on the tremendous cost of internal trade barriers to the economy and to households across Canada, and called for a grand bargain to bring collaborative action in the national interest.

“Our commitment to a national vision has eroded over the past few decades.  We have taken some small positive steps but we need to think bigger and move faster,” Pallister said.  “We need leadership in order to rediscover the blueprint for Confederation.”

In his release to the media, Pallister commented that he has sent a letter to fellow premiers seeking their support for a proposal to address two of the most important issues before Canadians:  sustainable and predictable federal support for health care, and reduction of inter-provincial trade barriers.

“I am proposing that we seek a commitment for stable federal health-care funding in return for our support for federal legislation establishing a Canadian economic union,” said Pallister. 

Most Canadians will be surprised to learn just how much the tangle of red tape, that ties up free trade between provinces, costs each and everyone of us.  According to Pallister, “... trade barriers cost Canadians the equivalent of a seven per cent sales tax.”

Pallister noted that while our premiers have ... recently made some modest progress on reducing trade barriers, we need to think much bigger in order to achieve the real results we all desire.

Reaction from the BC government, and in particular Minister Bruce Ralston’s Ministry of Trade, Jobs, and Technology, regrettably is not forthcoming on this topic. 

Hoping to see where the BC government is on taking down barriers, and perhaps getting a response to Premier Pallister's recent remarks, I commented to his Ministry:

The issue of trade across provincial borders seems to come up on a fairly regular basis, and so I am wondering what specific steps the BC government is taking to try and have rules, regulations, and red-tape reduced so that freer trade across Canada is available, and to make it easier for Canadian producers and manufacturers have better opportunity to sell to our own citizens.

The answer I received was, “Unfortunately, we don’t have anything we can share on this at this time.”

I honestly do not know if I was being told that Ralston’s Ministry actually did indeed have no information on the topic, or instead that they were unable to provide answers to what I requested. 

They are, in my opinion, indeed two separate things.  That said, I have to believe work is being done not only by our government in BC ... but across the country on this topic.  Either that, or Manitoba Premier Brian Pallister’s words are falling on deaf ears, at least here in BC.

He is stating that there needs to be discussions and proposals for federal legislation to establish the principle of free flow of goods and services within Canada. 

Furthermore, he believes that while provinces would retain the ultimate responsibility for removing barriers that fall under exclusive provincial jurisdiction, federal legislation would empower Canadians to challenge all barriers that obstruct their right to buy, sell, work and invest in every part of Canada.

“The grand bargain we envision with the federal government would allow us to pursue real nation building,” said Pallister. 

He also remarked he was looking forward to hearing the thoughts and feedback of his provincial and territorial colleagues on the topic. 

Hopefully he’ll have better luck than I, as a British Columbian, did when asking that very thing of my own government

As Brian Lee Crowley, managing director at the Macdonald-Laurier Institute said, “(Brian Pallister) is issuing a constructive challenge to his fellow premiers to move beyond entrenched positions and work together to make progress on two issues that matter enormously to Canadians.  That’s leadership.”

And as a story from Macleans magazine last October observed ... a solid majority of Canadians wants to see those impediments to the free flow of goods and services inside the country eliminated ... inter-provincial trade barriers should be scrapped because they “restrict choice and competitiveness in Canada’s consumer markets ...

And finally, I do indeed hope to hear back from the BC government on what is being done with regards to making inter-provincial trade between provinces easier – it’s an important topic – one that while help grow the economy, create more jobs, and save with reduced costs for each of us.

I look forward to clarity on their answer ... and a reconsideration of providing a response on this topic.

I’m Alan Forseth in Kamloops.  Please take a moment to share any thoughts you have on this commentary in the Comment Section below.  And as always, I encourage you to pass this on to any you feel may be interested.

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Okanagan Farmers Face NDP-Created Water Crisis ~~ BC Conservatives

Okanagan farmers are facing a water crisis as government-imposed restrictions threaten to kill their crops and destroy one of B.C.’s most important agricultural industries. In perhaps the most water-rich province in the country, our farmers have been left high and dry by the NDP government. For nine weeks, Okanagan and Shuswap farmers have proposed solutions, only to be met with NDP foot-dragging. Now forest fires have come to these regions as they are simultaneously reckoning with a water crisis that has been made worse through years of government inaction. Vernon-area farms have lost 70 percent of their water, while Kelowna and Summerland growers face severe restrictions. This situation is unacceptable and cannot continue. Ian Paton, Shadow Minister for Agriculture, said the NDP is once again forcing farmers to pay for its own failure to plan. "Farmers and ranchers must be listened to when decisions affecting their livelihoods are made, and under the NDP, they aren’t," said...

Khadr played upon the democratic freedoms and rights that Canadian have

WELL I CERTAINLY STIRRED UP REACTION when my last post went online , as well as other comments, which were made online elsewhere.  People opposed, to what I had to say, had comments which included the following:   Okay, I'm f - - king sick of the idiocy and done with writing a diatribe every single time a friend posts about how they're upset that Trudeau is giving a terrorist $10m. ... You people are.... willfully ignorant and hypocritical .. ·          God help us. What’s next everybody is “packing”, burning crosses, and having segregated bathrooms.  This rhetoric is disturbing.  Canadians are better than this. My mind is in awe of the number of people who have no respect for what being tortured actually means. Who foolishly think that they wouldn't break ... If our governments are willing to trap and torture people on foreign soil then we h...

Todd Stone and Peter Milobar, by all means possible, extort this government to end the never ending delaying process of review after review

With all the troubles and strife people in the Cached Creek / Ashcroft area ... and all the way through, and just past, Williams Lake are going through ... it's hard to get worked up -- annoyed -- or just plain miffed at matters that are political in nature. Kamloops City Councilor Denis Walsh I mean, really it is.  WITH ONE EXCEPTION.  The recent letter written by Kamloops City Councillor Denis Walsh.  To be fair (to me that is), I did wait five days while I let things simmer to see if what I had thought up first reading his letter, had changed it all. It did not. The letter Denis Walsh wrote to Christy Clark, Andrew Weaver, and soon to be Premier John Horgan had all of the hallmarks of the rabid opposition that has been stirred up for several years now. It was all filled with all of the buzz words, of doom and gloom, that one would expect ... and even more.  Those included: ...policies on the Ajax mine appr...

Labels

Show more