Skip to main content

“I am a Canadian, free to speak without fear, free to worship in my own way, free to stand for what I think right, free to oppose what I believe wrong, or free to choose those who shall govern my country. This heritage of freedom I pledge to uphold for myself and all mankind.” ~~ John G. Diefenbaker

FELDSTED: Omitted from assessment by the majority is whether or not carbon emission reductions are in the national interest


The Saskatchewan Appeal Court ruling on the carbon tax was disappointing, but unsurprising.

In my opinion, the federal government is determination to push through a new tax on Canadians irrespective of the economic and social fallout.

There is a sharp contrast between the approaches and assessments of the majority and minority views in this split decision. Writing for the majority, Richards, C.J.S. states:

“Canada contends it should be recognized, under the national concern branch, as having jurisdiction over “the cumulative dimensions of GHG emissions”. This approach must be rejected because it would allow Parliament to intrude so deeply into areas of provincial authority that the balance of federalism would be upset. Further, it would hamper and limit provincial efforts to deal with GHG emissions.”

“However, Parliament does have authority over a narrower POGG subject matter – the establishment of minimum national standards of price stringency for GHG emissions. This jurisdiction has the singleness, distinctiveness and indivisibility required by the law. It also has a limited impact on the balance of federalism and leaves provinces broad scope to legislate in the GHG area. The Act is constitutionally valid because its essential character falls within the scope of this POGG authority.”

Writing for the minority, Ottenbreit, J.A. states:

“Parliament and the Provincial legislatures are sovereign within their own heads of power or spheres of jurisdiction. Canadian federalism enshrines the principle of autonomy at each level of government so as to permit independent development and promotion of local and national political and policy priorities within the enumerated heads of power. 

The object of the Constitution Act, 1867 was not to “weld the provinces into one, nor to subordinate Provincial Governments to a central authority” (Re The Initiative and Referendum Act, [1919] AC 935 (PC) at 942).”

The Court of Appeal for Saskatchewan
Omitted from assessment by the majority is whether or not carbon emission reductions are in the national interest. Concerns over anthropogenic carbon emissions are driven by international treaty. Many nations are excluded from compliance and others have withdrawn support or do not support the Paris Agreement.

Stating that carbon emission goals are in Canada’s national interest is a dubious claim at best.

The issue at hand is whether the federal government can use its participation in an international treaty as a lever to alter the balance of powers between the federal and provincial governments.

The essence of Canadian sovereignty over her internal affairs is on the table, and these issues are far from resolved.  


John Feldsted
Political Consultant & Strategist
Winnipeg, Manitoba

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Okanagan Farmers Face NDP-Created Water Crisis ~~ BC Conservatives

Okanagan farmers are facing a water crisis as government-imposed restrictions threaten to kill their crops and destroy one of B.C.’s most important agricultural industries. In perhaps the most water-rich province in the country, our farmers have been left high and dry by the NDP government. For nine weeks, Okanagan and Shuswap farmers have proposed solutions, only to be met with NDP foot-dragging. Now forest fires have come to these regions as they are simultaneously reckoning with a water crisis that has been made worse through years of government inaction. Vernon-area farms have lost 70 percent of their water, while Kelowna and Summerland growers face severe restrictions. This situation is unacceptable and cannot continue. Ian Paton, Shadow Minister for Agriculture, said the NDP is once again forcing farmers to pay for its own failure to plan. "Farmers and ranchers must be listened to when decisions affecting their livelihoods are made, and under the NDP, they aren’t," said...

Khadr played upon the democratic freedoms and rights that Canadian have

WELL I CERTAINLY STIRRED UP REACTION when my last post went online , as well as other comments, which were made online elsewhere.  People opposed, to what I had to say, had comments which included the following:   Okay, I'm f - - king sick of the idiocy and done with writing a diatribe every single time a friend posts about how they're upset that Trudeau is giving a terrorist $10m. ... You people are.... willfully ignorant and hypocritical .. ·          God help us. What’s next everybody is “packing”, burning crosses, and having segregated bathrooms.  This rhetoric is disturbing.  Canadians are better than this. My mind is in awe of the number of people who have no respect for what being tortured actually means. Who foolishly think that they wouldn't break ... If our governments are willing to trap and torture people on foreign soil then we h...

Todd Stone and Peter Milobar, by all means possible, extort this government to end the never ending delaying process of review after review

With all the troubles and strife people in the Cached Creek / Ashcroft area ... and all the way through, and just past, Williams Lake are going through ... it's hard to get worked up -- annoyed -- or just plain miffed at matters that are political in nature. Kamloops City Councilor Denis Walsh I mean, really it is.  WITH ONE EXCEPTION.  The recent letter written by Kamloops City Councillor Denis Walsh.  To be fair (to me that is), I did wait five days while I let things simmer to see if what I had thought up first reading his letter, had changed it all. It did not. The letter Denis Walsh wrote to Christy Clark, Andrew Weaver, and soon to be Premier John Horgan had all of the hallmarks of the rabid opposition that has been stirred up for several years now. It was all filled with all of the buzz words, of doom and gloom, that one would expect ... and even more.  Those included: ...policies on the Ajax mine appr...

Labels

Show more