RUSTAD: Zero Emission Vehicles? BC collects significant gasoline taxes which pays for transit as well as road maintenance and upgrades. If nobody is buying gasoline, how will this bill be paid
The NDP passed a bill this spring requiring
BC to sell nothing but Zero Emission Vehicles by 2040. Was this a good piece of
legislation?
In my opinion, the goal of having people drive
a zero-emission vehicle is a good one, but what the bill did NOT do was explain
how this could be achieved.
First, where will the electricity come from?
With expected population growth, BC will require the equivalent of 4 Site C
dams in production, to meet the electrical demand
from electric vehicles. Now some of those vehicles may be hydrogen but the
result would be the same as the production of hydrogen still requires
electricity.
How will this amount
of electricity be created?
Some say from solar or wind. Those are fine
but how will that power be firmed. Also, are you prepared to pay skyrocketing
electricity prices? That is what this bill by the NDP will mean.
How is that making life more affordable?
Second, high speed charging stations requires
significant transmission capabilities. Most (if not all) neighborhoods in
existence today do not have the capacity to enable the number of charging
stations required.
In other words, there will need to be a HUGE
investment in upgrading BC’s transmission capabilities both in the general grid,
as well as at the household level. Who will pay for this and what is the cost?
I will speculate that the cost will be in the hundreds of billions of dollars
which will need to be paid by tax payers.
Once again, how does this make life more
affordable?
Third, BC collects significant gasoline taxes
which pays for transit as well as road maintenance and upgrades. If nobody is
buying gasoline, how will this bill be paid?
Forth, the range of electric vehicles is very
limited. For example, an EV would not even have the capacity for me to drive
from one side of my riding to the other, not to mention trying to get home in
the same day. How will the vast distances of our great provinces be addressed
for people who require to drive for work, health appointments, school, etc...?
The BC NDP’s zero emission vehicle bill
certainly appears to be about politics as clearly, there are no plans to
address even these basic issues. To realistically achieve a 2040 goal, BC would
need to start making plans and investments TODAY to address these issues.
AND ... this doesn’t even include the
environmental impacts that would need to be addressed due to disposing of batteries
and other issues associated with electric vehicles.
NOR ... according to one individual commenting to John on this
... does it consider what happens when the batteries reach
the end and must be replaced. I imagine that would run many thousands that a
lot of families don't or won't have.
And as for the
distance one would be able to travel on a single charge? Another commented to
John that where he lived (in the city) he could get 400km on a charge, and
that traveling from south to north borders of BC will require two full
recharges, which with a DC fast charge will take an hour each.
Seeing as MLA Rustad lives in the Nechako riding, I’m not surprised
when he responded by stating:
“400km range... hmmm? My riding is about 280kms, along Highway 16, one way. And how long does it take to recharge? Oh yah, don't turn on the heater or the air conditioning because you certainly won't get 400km range.”
“400km range... hmmm? My riding is about 280kms, along Highway 16, one way. And how long does it take to recharge? Oh yah, don't turn on the heater or the air conditioning because you certainly won't get 400km range.”
I’m with you on this
one John.
John Rustad worked
in the forest industry in logging and forest management. He started and
operated Western Geographic Information Systems Inc. from 1995 to 2002 where he
was engaged in forestry consulting.
John was first
elected to the BC Legislature in 2005 and was re-elected in 2009, 2013 and
2017. He served in various capacities including parliamentary secretary for
Silviculture, parliamentary secretary for Forests, Minister of Aboriginal
Relations and Reconciliation and Minister of Forests, Lands and Natural
Resource Operations.
He is currently
the critic for Forests, Lands, Natural Resource Operations and Rural
Development.
Comments
Post a Comment