ERIN OTOOLE: While the SNC scandal is deeply troubling to many observers, it is not even the most serious example of the Trudeau government’s disregard for the rule of law
Over
the last few months, Canadians have been transfixed by the SNC Lavalin scandal.
What began as a headline in the Globe & Mail alongside flat denials by the
Prime Minister, led to the resignation of two top Liberal cabinet ministers.
The self-styled “feminist” Prime Minister was forced to toss two of his best
MPs out of the Liberal caucus in a clear effort to save his political skin. For
many Canadians it was the first time the curtain was pulled back on Justin
Trudeau and his team.
Vice - Admiral Mark Norman |
While
conduct in the SNC scandal is deeply troubling to many observers, it is not
even the most serious example of the Trudeau government’s disregard for the
rule of law. In my view, that distinction goes to the Admiral Mark Norman
affair, where the liberty of an honourable Canadian is at stake.
Vice-Admiral
Mark Norman has served thirty-eight years in the Canadian Armed Forces. He was
the second highest ranking official in our military and has been decorated by
Canada and our allies. Like so many members of the Canadian Armed Forces,
Norman grew up in a military family. Therefore, his entire life has been spent
either serving Canada himself, or as part of a military family serving the
country.
This is
why I believe that the Admiral Norman affair is far more disturbing than the
SNC scandal. One deals with a corporation and efforts by the Liberal government
to assist it, while the other deals with one of our best citizens and actions
by the Liberal government that have hindered his legal rights.
The roots of this affair take
us back to the very origin story of the Trudeau government. We all remember the
carefully staged stroll up Rideau Hall for Trudeau and his cabinet. He pledged
they would be “transparent by default”, yet within days they were secretly
interfering in a $700 million naval contract.
In
November 2015, the House of Commons had not yet been sworn in following the
election, but one or more Liberal Ministers attempted to halt a contract in
their first cabinet meeting. The contract at issue was one geared at getting
our Navy a much-needed supply ship after fire had taken our last remaining one
out of service.
We might not even know about
the interference in this first cabinet meeting were it not for the reporting of
a CBC journalist. James Cudmore wrote
about the cabinet review of the contract and the interventions by
private industry that came before the cabinet meeting. The CBC stories by
Cudmore led to two things. First, the government decided to proceed with the
original contract. And second, James Cudmore stopped reporting for the CBC.
In a
move that raised many eyebrows, Cudmore accepted a job from the Liberal
government weeks later. He went from covering defence issues as a journalist to
advising the Liberal Defence Minister.
The leaks surrounding the shipbuilding
contract led to a furor in Ottawa and an investigation revealed that dozens of
people were aware of details from the cabinet meeting. A year later, Mark
Norman was suspended from his job as Vice-Chief of Defence Staff. He was
charged with a single charge of breach of trust a year after his suspension.
I have
yet to hear any reasonable suggestion as to what personal benefit Mark Norman
would have received in relation to this alleged breach of trust. The Crown will
need to prove this element of the offence and I don’t think that ensuring his
naval comrades got “the kit” they needed is going to cut it.
The troubling pattern of
apparent interference by the Trudeau government arose before charges were laid.
On two
separate occasions, the Prime Minister alluded to the fact that criminal
charges were likely against Mark Norman. Either he misspoke on two occasions,
or he was aware of details related to the investigation. Even worse is the fact
that the Trudeau government resisted disclosure of documents needed by Admiral
Norman for his defence.
After
months of pressure, the government finally agreed to let the judge review the
documents for relevance, but this made the process slow. The judge also
chastised the government for releasing duplicate documents that bogged down the
review. Court documents have also revealed that the Privy Council Office
appears to have been getting updates from the prosecution team on “trial
strategy” in a manner that Norman’s lawyers have suggested was improper.
The most disturbing part of the
Norman affair is its similarities to the Ontario gas plant scandal.
Not
only are many of the principal players from the Ontario Liberal team working in
the Trudeau government, but lawyers at the Norman trial are raising questions
about practices that appear similar to those used in the gas plant scandal.
In the
gas plant scandal, the McGuinty government used code words like “Apple” and
“Vapour”, which had the effect of delaying or avoiding disclosure of documents.
Admiral Norman’s lawyers have been asking witnesses about code words like
“Kraken” or “CN3” and whether officials within the Defence Department or the
Prime Minister’s Office used code words to avoid disclosure.
It will
be up to the court to determine whether code words were used. or whether there
was inappropriate direction from the Prime Minister and his advisors in the
Admiral Norman affair, but after the SNC scandal you will understand why many observers
don’t give them the benefit of the doubt.
Conservative MP Erin O'Toole |
Until
the trial is complete or charges withdrawn, Admiral Mark Norman marches into
court and not across the parade square. I hope he gets justice and until then I
salute him for his service and tremendous resilience throughout this terrible
ordeal.
Erin O’Toole is the Member of Parliament for
the riding of Durham (Ontario) and the Official Opposition Shadow Minister for
Foreign Affairs and International Development.
He was first elected to Parliament in a 2012
by-election and re-elected in the 2015 general election.
In the Conservative government he served as
the Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister of International Trade before his
appointment to cabinet as Canada’s Minister of Veterans Affairs.
Comments
Post a Comment